Home Prompt

IWC workflow pull request review command

Vendored IWC command for reviewing a workflow pull request against the contributor and reviewer checklist.

Revised
2026-09-12
Rev
3

Vendored from the proposed upstream review overhaul, pinned at SHA d7012eb. The raw prompt lives next to this note as upstream.prompt.

When to consult: as upstream procedural evidence for a Mold that reviews an IWC or IWC Lab workflow submission. This is a repository-local review command, not a GitHub Actions workflow.

The command is the consolidated IWC workflow-review procedure. It tells an agent to read policy from the pull request base, inspect relevant CI evidence and complete files, assess every checklist item, distinguish required fixes from optional improvements, and return an evidenced advisory recommendation. Consumers should treat it as a pinned procedure rather than permanently current policy.

Casting consumes upstream.prompt verbatim. This wrapper exists for Foundry metadata, provenance, and human-facing usage guidance.

Provenance and acceptance status

  • Pin of record: the vendored_upstreams.yml entry for upstream.prompt. That entry, this note’s sources: URL, and the blockquote above are the only places this repository states the SHA. No Mold, eval, scenario, or Pipeline restates it; a runtime reports the hash recorded for this reference in its cast’s provenance record instead.
  • Acceptance: proposed, not accepted. galaxyproject/iwc#1366 is still open, so this pin is a proposed revision of the review policy rather than accepted upstream policy. Anything consuming it should say so.
  • Claude-versus-Copilot superset comparison: not yet performed. Record the finding here once #1366 is accepted. If the accepted command is not a semantic superset of copilot-workflow-review-instructions, record the specific gaps here and resolve them upstream, or revisit the one-pass decision explicitly rather than silently dropping the difference.

Refreshing the pin is: re-vendor upstream.prompt, update the vendored_upstreams.yml entry, update sources:, the blockquote, this section, revised:, and revision: — then make casts. Nothing else in the repository needs to change.

Incoming References (3)

  • mature-galaxy-workflow-for-iwc related note — Apply the IWC publication checklist to an existing Galaxy workflow and emit a generalized, reviewable submission set.
  • review-galaxy-workflow related note — Apply the pinned upstream IWC review policy to one Galaxy workflow or pull request and emit one evidenced advisory Markdown review.
  • GALAXY WORKFLOW REVIEW related note — Post-construction review journey: summarize, validate, and test an existing Galaxy workflow, then apply pinned IWC policy.